Empirical Metric · Pillar 1: Executive Deactivation & Flow
Network Reconfiguration in Drumming-Induced Shamanic Trance (Hove et al., 2016)
- Classification
- fMRI connectivity study of drumming-induced trance in experienced practitioners
- Acquisition vector
- Within-subject fMRI (eigenvector centrality and seed-based connectivity) with EEG
- Retention loop
- Cited for network reconfiguration and perceptual decoupling in trance, including by Wood (2020)
Direct answer
Hove et al. (2016) scanned 15 experienced shamanic practitioners with fMRI while they listened to rhythmic drumming and either entered trance or stayed in a nontrance state (Cerebral Cortex 26(7), 3116–3124). Trance was associated with “higher eigenvector centrality (i.e., stronger hubs) in 3 regions: posterior cingulate cortex (PCC), dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC), and left insula/operculum,” stronger PCC coupling with control-network regions, and weaker connectivity within the auditory pathway, which the authors read as possible perceptual decoupling. EEG theta power did not differ between conditions.
I. Participants and Procedure
Participants were “15 experienced shamanic practitioners (mean age ± SD, 50.2 ± 8.3 years; range 38–65; 11 female)” from Germany and Austria, with an average of 9.3 years of practice. Each listened to drumming during 8-minute scans and either entered trance or stayed in a nontrance state.
The trance drumming was “a relatively isochronous pulse” (mean interonset interval 236 ms, 4.24 Hz; SD 6.7 ms). The nontrance track used the same sounds and mean tempo with more irregular timing (SD 16.5 ms).
II. Findings
| Measure | Trance compared with nontrance |
|---|---|
| Eigenvector centrality (hub strength) | Higher in PCC, dACC, left anterior insula/operculum |
| Seed-based connectivity | PCC more coactive with dACC and insula (“an internally oriented neural stream was amplified by the modulatory control network”) |
| Auditory pathway | Seeds “less connected, possibly indicating perceptual decoupling and suppression of the repetitive auditory stimuli” |
| EEG theta power | “comparable in both conditions” |
The EEG result bears on an older idea. Neher (1962) had proposed that drumming drives brain rhythms at the drum frequency; Hove et al. report that “the current data did not support auditory driving of cortex.” They relate the absorptive state to “the hyper-focused immersive experience of flow” and distinguish it from hypnosis: both involve “focused attention and dissociation from competing thoughts (Spiegel 2013). However, they differ in the orientation of attention.”
III. Limits and Use
The authors note that the study “did not include naïve controls, so the generalizability of the effects to the wider population is unclear.” They point to other work suggesting naïve subjects can be studied, including Maurer et al. (1997), in which drumming-induced trance states were deeper in more hypnotizable naïve subjects.
The PCC finding runs against any simple claim that trance quiets the default network: here the PCC became a stronger hub. Wood (2020) cites the study for internal-state networks being active and sensory input being decoupled during rhythm-induced trance (p. 138).
Relational knowledge graph
Outgoing edges
- Measured by rhythmic auditory driving · Induction VectorRhythmic Auditory Driving and Acoustic EntrainmentTests rhythmic drumming as a trance inducer; theta power did not differ between trance and nontrance, so the data “did not support auditory driving of cortex.”
- Explained by Andrew Neher · EntityHove et al. cite Neher (1962) on auditory driving by drumming and report that their EEG data did not support it.
- Explained by default mode network downregulation · MechanismDefault Mode Network Downregulation During Present-Centered AttentionContrast: the PCC, a default-network hub, became a stronger hub in trance and was more coupled with control-network regions.
- Measured by Wood antistructure · FrameworkWood’s Antistructure and the Roots of Religious Experience (2020)Wood (2020, pp. 138, 143) cites this study for internal-state networks being active and sensory input decoupled during rhythm-induced trance.
- Explained by Csikszentmihalyi flow theory · FrameworkCsikszentmihalyi’s Flow TheoryThe authors relate trance absorption to “the hyper-focused immersive experience of flow” (citing Csikszentmihalyi, 1990). Flow was not measured.
- Explained by neodissociation theory · FrameworkHilgard’s Neodissociation Theory of Divided ConsciousnessInterpretive parallel: the authors compare trance with hypnosis (citing Spiegel, 2013) and cite Maurer et al. (1997) for deeper drumming trance in more hypnotizable naïve subjects. They do not cite Hilgard.
- Explained by binaural beats · Induction VectorBinaural Beat Stimulation and the Brainwave-Entrainment HypothesisRelated null for rhythmic driving: Hove et al. (2016) found comparable theta power in trance and non-trance drumming. For binaural beats, Ingendoh et al. (2023) found no consistent EEG entrainment across 14 studies.
- Explained by trance · MechanismTrance: Narrowed Awareness, Absorption and Its Clinical BoundariesGeneral trance page, which uses this study’s definition of trance (“narrowed awareness of external surroundings”) and sets it beside the WHO clinical boundary for trance disorder.
- Explained by altered states of consciousness · FrameworkAltered States of Consciousness: Definitions, Routes and MeasuresHub page, which places drumming-induced trance within the wider classification of altered states (Vaitl et al., 2005).
← Back to the Transcendence Directory
Editorial Notice: Entry in this directory represents academic, neuro-somatic, and sociological classification based on peer-reviewed literature and does not constitute a legal finding or medical diagnosis. Corrections:geniustolife@gmail.com