Framework · Pillar 5: Non-Dogmatic Ego Dissolution & Secular Self-Transcendence
Kitson et al.’s Review of Self-Transcendence Research Methods (2020)
- Classification
- Methodological review: how self-transcendence is defined, theorized, and measured
- Acquisition vector
- Narrative review of theories and of questionnaire, diary, interview, physiological and behavioral methods
- Retention loop
- Cited as a map of instruments and a case for multi-method designs in self-transcendence research
Direct answer
Kitson, Chirico, Gaggioli & Riecke (2020) is a review of how researchers define and measure self-transcendence, published in Frontiers in Psychology (11, 547687). It groups theories as conceptual, phenomenological, or physiological, and methods as questionnaires, diaries, interviews, neurological/physiological measures, and behavioral observation. Because the construct is defined in many ways, the authors recommend “a multi-method approach” and point to neurophenomenology. They also warn that researchers need to be clear whether they are measuring “self-transcendence or its outcome.”
I. Definition and Scope
Kitson et al. adopt the definition of Yaden et al. (2017): self-transcendence is decreased self-saliency together with increased connection to others and the environment. They note that the term covers very different things. Citing Wong (2016), they write that self-transcendence “can be regarded as a psychological state, personality trait, developmental process, value orientation, motivation, and worldview.” As an experience it is “multifaceted in itself, composed of mindfulness, flow, self-transcendent emotions, awe, peak experiences, and mystical experiences (Yaden et al., 2017a)”.
The review sorts existing theories into “three categories: conceptual, phenomenological, and physiological.” The conceptual group starts with Frankl. The physiological group covers proposals about the default mode network, parietal regions, neuropeptides, and the vagus nerve.
II. Methods and Recommended Instruments
The review covers five kinds of method: questionnaires and surveys, diaries or journals, interviews, neurological and physiological recordings, and behavioral observation. For measuring a state of self-transcendence as it happens, the authors suggest a set of questionnaires:
| Instrument | Facet it targets | Reliability as reported by Kitson et al. |
|---|---|---|
| Awe Experience Scale (AWE-S) | Awe, six factors | α from .80 to .91 by factor; .93 overall |
| Toronto Mindfulness Scale (TMS) | Mindful decentering | (see review) |
| NADA-S | Nondual awareness | (see review) |
| Inclusion of Other in Self Scale (IOS) | Self–other overlap | test-retest r = 0.83 overall |
| Dispositional Positive Emotion Scales (DPES) | Self-transcendent emotions | (see review) |
| Mysticism Scale (MS) | Mystical experience | (see review) |
They pair these with observation, micro-phenomenological interviews, physiological recording, and diaries. They treat α ≥ 0.70 as acceptable and note that only about half of the questionnaires they reviewed had been tested for test-retest reliability. Their main methodological proposal is neurophenomenology, “the synthesis of neuroimaging to provide rich empirical data (e.g., EEG, MRI, PET) and valid descriptions of first-person subjective experience.”
III. Cautions the Review Raises
- Physiology is not specific. The authors caution that physiological measures pick up arousal and valence rather than a discrete state, and report the view of some researchers that there is no physiological “finger print” for an emotion.
- Neuropeptide claims are thin in humans. On oxytocin and vasopressin they write that “the research on these neuropeptides is based on animal models, so the validity of these claims for humans is limited.”
- Proxies are not the thing itself. Self-transcendence correlates with outcomes such as self-diminishment and prosocial behavior, but “researchers need to be clear on what exactly they measure—self-transcendence or its outcome.”
- Default-mode findings are partial. Reduced default mode network activity has been reported in contemplative practice and in one awe-video study (van Elk & Rotteveel, 2019). The same study found that induced awe did not change time perception.
The review is a narrative synthesis, not a meta-analysis; it reports reliability figures from the original scale papers rather than testing them anew.
Relational knowledge graph
Outgoing edges
- Explained by self-transcendent experience · FrameworkThe Varieties of Self-Transcendent Experience (Yaden et al., 2017)Kitson et al. take their working definition from Yaden et al. (2017): decreased self-saliency and increased connection to others and the environment.
- Explained by Paul Wong self-transcendence · FrameworkWong’s Meaning-Seeking and Self-Transcendence (2016)Kitson et al. cite Wong (2016) for self-transcendence being regarded as “a psychological state, personality trait, developmental process, value orientation, motivation, and worldview.”
- Measured by Awe Experience Scale · Empirical MetricAwe Experience Scale (AWE-S)The AWE-S is the first of the in-the-moment questionnaires Kitson et al. recommend; they report internal consistency for each of its six factors.
- Measured by NADA · Empirical MetricNondual Awareness Dimensional Assessment (NADA)Kitson et al. recommend the state form of the Nondual Awareness Dimensional Assessment (NADA-S) for in-the-moment self-transcendence.
- Measured by Inclusion of Other in the Self scale · Empirical MetricInclusion of Other in the Self ScaleKitson et al. recommend the Inclusion of Other in Self Scale and report test-retest reliability of r = 0.83 overall.
- Measured by Ego-Dissolution Inventory · Empirical MetricKitson et al. review the Ego-Dissolution Inventory as a consciousness-related measure of self-transcendence.
- Measured by Flow State Scale-2 · Empirical MetricFlow State Scale–2Kitson et al. list the Flow State Scale, FSS-2 and Dispositional Flow Scale-2 (Jackson and colleagues) as flow measures within self-transcendence research.
- Explained by default mode network downregulation · MechanismDefault Mode Network Downregulation During Present-Centered AttentionKitson et al. report reduced default mode network activity in contemplative practice and in one awe-video study (van Elk & Rotteveel, 2019), while warning that physiological measures index arousal and valence generally.
- Measured by muse headband · Empirical MetricEEG Meditation Headbands: What the Muse Studies ShowKitson et al. note that consumer EEG products make EEG accessible to researchers; the headband page reviews how well one such device performs.
Reciprocal links (resolved at build)
- Explains group singing oxytocin · Empirical MetricSalivary Oxytocin and Cortisol After Group Singing (Bowling et al., 2022)Kitson et al. (2020) caution that neuropeptide claims rest mostly on animal models; Bowling et al. add that salivary oxytocin may not reflect central release.
← Back to the Transcendence Directory
Editorial Notice: Entry in this directory represents academic, neuro-somatic, and sociological classification based on peer-reviewed literature and does not constitute a legal finding or medical diagnosis. Corrections:geniustolife@gmail.com