Mechanism · Pillar 5: Non-Dogmatic Ego Dissolution & Secular Self-Transcendence
Awe, the Small Self, and Prosocial Behavior (Piff et al., 2015)
- Classification
- Proposed psychological mechanism with experimental support: awe → diminished self → prosocial behavior
- Acquisition vector
- Five studies (N = 2,078): national survey, narrative recall, video inductions, and an outdoor tree-gazing experiment
- Retention loop
- Cited as the main experimental evidence linking awe to generosity and reduced entitlement
Direct answer
The small-self account of awe comes from Piff, Dietze, Feinberg, Stancato & Keltner (2015, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 108(6), 883–899). Across five studies (N = 2,078), awe predicted or increased generosity, ethical decisions, prosocial values and helping, and lowered entitlement. Mediation analyses indicated the effects were “explained, in part, by feelings of a small self”: “a relative diminishment of the individual self and its interests vis-à-vis something perceived to be more vast and powerful than oneself.”
I. The Proposed Mechanism
Piff et al. start from Keltner & Haidt’s (2003) account: awe is a response to vastness that calls for accommodation. They draw on treatments of awe as a collective emotion (Durkheim and later authors), which propose that awe helps people fold into groups by shifting attention away from the self. Their hypothesis is a chain:
awe → a small self (the self and its goals feel less significant next to something vaster) → more prosocial behavior.
They define the small self as “a relative diminishment of the individual self and its interests vis-à-vis something perceived to be more vast and powerful than oneself” and separate it from low self-worth. Awe inductions produced happiness comparable to other positive emotions, which the authors read as evidence that the small self is not an injury to self-esteem.
II. The Five Studies
| Study | Sample | Awe measure or induction | Comparison | Main result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1,519 adults, national panel | Trait awe (DPES-r, α = .83) | Other positive emotions as covariates | Awe predicted giving in an economic game; effect “modest”; not significant for the $10 version alone |
| 2 | Online adults | Recall of awe in nature | Pride, neutral | More ethical decisions; mediated by a single “something greater than myself” item |
| 3 | 254 students (analyzed) | Five-minute vast-nature video | Amusing nature video, neutral | More generosity; small self higher than amusement (d = 0.83) and mediated the effect |
| 4 | 100 online adults (analyzed) | Threatening-nature or non-nature awe video | Neutral | More prosocial choices; the self-diminishment facet, not vastness, carried the mediation |
| 5 | 90 students | One minute looking up at eucalyptus trees over 200 feet tall | Looking up at a tall building | More pens picked up for an experimenter (d = .45); lower entitlement composite (d = 1.04) |
The researchers took care to separate awe from general positive mood (Studies 2 and 3) and from nature exposure as such (Study 3 used nature footage in both conditions).
III. Limits and Wider Claims
- Size and design. Study 1 is correlational and its effect was described by the authors as “modest.” The mediator in Study 2 was a single item. Studies 2–5 measured short-term responses in one session.
- Self-report mediators. The small self was measured with ad hoc self-report items; later work developed the multi-factor Awe Experience Scale.
- From awe to institutions. In closing, the authors suggest that “religions represent social institutions that elicit, organize, and ritualize awe” and that some prosocial effects of religion may be partly due to awe. They offer this as a hypothesis for future research.
The study was supported in part by the John Templeton Foundation (grant 24288 to Keltner). One measure in Study 5, the Psychological Entitlement Scale, shares the abbreviation “PES” with the unrelated Perceived Emotional Synchrony Scale elsewhere in this directory.
Relational knowledge graph
Outgoing edges
- Explained by Keltner Haidt awe · FrameworkKeltner & Haidt’s Prototype Approach to Awe (2003)Piff et al. define awe following Keltner & Haidt (2003) as a response to “perceptually vast stimuli that transcend current frames of reference” and test a consequence the earlier paper proposed.
- Authored by Dacher Keltner · EntityDacher Keltner is the senior (fifth) author of Piff, Dietze, Feinberg, Stancato & Keltner (2015).
- Explained by self-transcendent experience · FrameworkThe Varieties of Self-Transcendent Experience (Yaden et al., 2017)Awe is one of the self-transcendent emotions in Yaden et al.’s (2017) framework; the small self corresponds to its annihilational, self-diminishing side.
- Measured by Awe Experience Scale · Empirical MetricAwe Experience Scale (AWE-S)Self-diminishment is one of the six AWE-S factors (Yaden et al., 2018), a later standardized measure of the state Piff et al. measured with ad hoc items.
- Measured by Inclusion of Other in the Self scale · Empirical MetricInclusion of Other in the Self ScalePiff et al. cite Van Cappellen & Saroglou (2012) for an awe video raising felt connection to people in general on the IOS scale. As cited; not part of these five studies.
- Explained by Émile Durkheim · EntityThe authors ground their hypothesis in treatments of awe as a collective emotion, beginning with Durkheim (1887).
- Explained by William James · EntityThe paper opens with James’s (1902) account of saintliness, in which “the outlines of the confining selfhood melt down.” A framing quotation.
- Explained by awe definition · MechanismAwe: Definition and ScienceThe emotion behind the small-self effect: definition, common triggers, threat-based awe and the limits of current evidence.
- Measured by DRH New Religiosity Poll · Empirical MetricNew Religiosity and the Digital Study of Eudaimonia (DRH New Religiosity Poll, JTF Grant #63357)Comparative group-level complement: whereas Piff et al. (2015) test short-term prosociality and self-diminishment in individuals, the DRH New Religiosity Poll tracks longitudinal prosociality, volunteerism, and eudaimonia indicators across contemporary movements.
← Back to the Transcendence Directory
Editorial Notice: Entry in this directory represents academic, neuro-somatic, and sociological classification based on peer-reviewed literature and does not constitute a legal finding or medical diagnosis. Corrections:geniustolife@gmail.com